Seven specific accusations of criminal conduct. That's what New York Times reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig packed into their 2024 book "Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father's Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success" — accusations of complex tax fraud and money laundering against Donald Trump and his father. No formal charges. No convictions. Just accusations dressed up as investigative journalism and sold by Penguin Random House.
On Wednesday, a federal judge said there's reason to believe they made it up.
U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday, sitting in Tampa, Florida, denied the New York Times' motion to dismiss four counts of President Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit. Counts I, II, V, and VI of Trump's amended complaint survive. Counts III and IV — tied to two separate newspaper articles — were dismissed, along with 27 individual statements the judge found legally insufficient to support defamation claims. But the core of the case, the book itself and its accusations of criminal tax conduct, moves to trial. The Times has 28 days to file a formal answer.
The judge's reasoning landed like a brick through a newsroom window. Merryday wrote that "the facts alleged in the complaint create at least a plausible inference that the authors and the publishers knew that no reliable conclusion about violations of the tax laws, including especially the estate and gift tax laws, is possible without reliance on qualified opinion formulated after the necessary factual and legal research and analysis, which they knowingly failed to obtain."
Translation: Buettner and Craig accused a sitting president of tax crimes without bothering to get a qualified expert to tell them whether the transactions they described actually broke the law. They skipped the homework and went straight to the printing press.
Merryday went further, noting that "even a qualified expert offering a superficial characterization such as a transaction is 'suspicious' or 'could' violate the law or attributing to a transaction the 'smell' of crime" falls "far from a formal legal opinion sufficient to remove serious doubt about the truthfulness and accuracy of a statement accusing a specific person of fraud or tax evasion or some related crime arising from a specific transaction." The word "smell" is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. A federal judge just told the paper of record that sniffing around isn't the same as proving something.
Trump's legal team didn't mince — well, they were direct. A spokesman said the ruling means "these defendants will now have to answer for intentionally and maliciously defaming President Trump," adding that "the New York Times has a long pattern of defaming President Trump in service of its leftist political agenda, and today's momentous ruling is a victory for honesty in America."
The Times, as reported by the Washington Examiner, responded with the kind of statement you write when you're pretending the building isn't on fire. A spokesperson said the paper is "encouraged to see Judge Merryday's dismissal of almost all claims" and "continue to believe the remaining claim in the filing has no legal merit." They called the lawsuit a "baseless attack on The Times and the rights of the free and independent press in this country."
Encouraged. Four defamation counts surviving a motion to dismiss under the New York Times Co. v. Sullivan standard — one of the highest bars in American law, designed specifically to protect the press from exactly this kind of lawsuit — and they're encouraged. Sullivan requires proof of actual malice, meaning the Times knew its statements were false or showed reckless disregard for the truth. A judge just ruled that Trump plausibly alleged they cleared that bar. That's not a nuisance suit surviving on a technicality. That's a federal court saying the evidence of malice is strong enough to open discovery.
Discovery. That's the part the Times should be thinking about. Because discovery means internal emails. It means editorial discussions about what Buettner and Craig actually knew versus what they printed. It means depositions under oath. Every newsroom conversation about whether the tax fraud accusations had adequate sourcing is now potentially on the table. The 12-page order didn't just keep the case alive — it opened the door to the Times' own records.
The judge did deny Trump's request to amend his complaint a third time. That's housekeeping. The substance is what matters: the book that accused a president of crimes without qualified legal analysis to support those accusations is now the centerpiece of a case headed toward trial.
Fifteen billion dollars. The Times' total revenue last year was a fraction of that number. Even if the final judgment is a tenth of the ask, the legal fees, the discovery process, and the public record of what the newsroom knew will cost more than money.
The last time the Times faced a defamation standard this high, they won. They wrote the precedent. Now they have to defend against it.