Jury Awards $150K to Female Inmate Forced to Share Cell With 6-Foot-4 Male Sex Offender

0
Jury Awards $150K to Female Inmate Forced to Share Cell With 6-Foot-4 Male Sex Offender

Mozzy Clark filed a PREA complaint before anything happened. She told the staff at Washington Corrections Center for Women in Tacoma that she didn't feel safe sharing space with Christopher Scott Williams — a six-foot-four male inmate previously incarcerated for sex crimes, who had been caught masturbating in front of female guards at his prior men's facility. Staff told Clark that if she complained, it would be considered a hate crime.

She complained anyway. A jury just handed her $150,000.

The verdict came down in Tacoma against the Washington State Department of Corrections, and the details are worse than the headline. Williams was denied transfer to the women's facility in 2019. By 2021, under revised DOC Policy 600-GU009 — which reviews gender-affirming housing requests on a case-by-case basis — he was approved. By 2022, he was placed directly in Clark's cell. Deputy Secretary Scott Russell, the final decisionmaker on inmate transfers, signed off.

Corrections officer Gregory Brooks knew exactly what he was approving. According to trial testimony reported by Just The News, Brooks acknowledged that Williams "was known to violently retaliate against women who complained." Brooks also told the court that Williams traded sex for items — a bag of chips was the going rate. The jury found that Brooks made an "intentional decision" that caused a substantial risk of sexual assault. They held him personally liable.

Sergeant Carrie Ann Williams was absolved. Brooks was not. The jury drew a line between following orders and making the call.

Clark wasn't the only victim. Faith Booher-Smith, another female inmate assaulted by Williams, is the co-plaintiff in a second trial scheduled for February 2027. The Justice Department has since launched a civil rights probe into WCCW.

The transgender population at the facility represented roughly 2% of inmates — approximately 15 people. The entire women's prison housing policy was restructured around accommodating that 2%. Clark's First, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendment rights were the cost of that restructuring.

Amie Ichikawa, founder of the Woman II Woman nonprofit and an advocate for the plaintiffs, put it plainly after the verdict: "I am so sorry that this is what it takes for the system to acknowledge that it is a female human rights violation to house predatory, opportunistic men in women's prisons — but I'll take it."

The defense argued that Clark — a woman who was beaten by a male inmate with a documented history of sexual violence and retaliation — had suffered no injury. That argument went to a jury of regular citizens in Tacoma, Washington. They looked at the facts and did what the corrections system refused to do for three years.

The state had every piece of information it needed. Williams's history was in the file. The PREA complaint was on record. The officer who approved the placement admitted he knew the risk. DOC Secretary Tim Lang's department processed the transfer anyway, because the policy said to evaluate requests case by case, and the case apparently didn't include the part about the sex crimes.

David Pivtorak, Clark's attorney, got $150,000 out of a system that told his client her safety concerns were a hate crime. February's trial will ask whether the system learned anything from the first verdict.

The America First Policy Institute and the Foundation Against Intolerance and Racism backed the legal effort. The jury didn't need persuading on ideology. They just needed the facts.


Most Popular

Most Popular