Five hundred and sixty-three people on California's death row just got the governor's personal guarantee that the state will never carry out their sentences. Some of them killed more than once. Some of them killed children. Governor Gavin Newsom halted the death penalty for every last one of them.
The families of the victims were not consulted.
President Trump responded on Friday with the kind of restraint Newsom probably wasn't hoping for. "Gavin Newscum's halting the Death Penalty for all 563 California Death Row inmates, some of the worst cold blooded murderers to have ever lived on the face of the Earth, is a disaster for Justice in America," Trump wrote.
He wasn't done. "Many of these names, people who have killed, over and over again, can't believe their luck in having a Governor so incompetent and insensitive that he would not let the long and winding legal system prevail," Trump continued. That phrase — "can't believe their luck" — is doing a lot of work. These are people who exhausted every appeal, sat through every hearing, watched the legal system grind through decades of due process, and arrived at a sentence. Newsom just waved it away.
This is the same California that will fine you for handing out plastic straws, prosecute you for misgendering someone at work, and ticket you for watering your lawn on the wrong day. The state has bandwidth for all of that. Executing convicted serial murderers, though — that's where Sacramento draws the line.
The math here tells you everything about Newsom's priorities. California has 563 inmates on death row. That's the largest death row population in the Western Hemisphere. These aren't people convicted of jaywalking. The "long and winding legal system" Trump referenced is the point — these cases were tried, appealed, reviewed, and affirmed over years and sometimes decades. Every procedural safeguard in the book was applied. The sentences stood. Until one man decided they shouldn't.
Newsom's position has never been that these people are innocent. He's never argued the trials were unfair. He's never pointed to a specific case where the evidence collapsed. His argument is philosophical — he just doesn't believe in the death penalty, period. Which is a fine opinion to hold at a dinner party. It's a different thing entirely when you're the governor of a state where voters have repeatedly chosen to keep capital punishment on the books. California voters rejected abolishing the death penalty in 2012 and again in 2016. Newsom's move isn't governance. It's overrule.
The "compassion" framing falls apart the moment you look at who's on that list. We're talking about people convicted of torturing and killing children, people who murdered multiple victims, people whose crimes were so extreme that juries — twelve ordinary Californians — decided death was the only proportionate response. Newsom's compassion runs in one direction: toward the people who did the killing, not toward the people they killed.
Trump closed with the part that matters most and gets talked about least: "The family members of those who were so viciously killed are, rightfully, devastated. Hopefully this decision will be overturned!" Those families sat through trials. They gave victim impact statements. They watched the system work. They were told there would be justice. Now they've been told, actually, the governor changed his mind.
California spent decades and millions of taxpayer dollars building cases, conducting trials, and processing appeals for 563 capital convictions. Every one of those cases ended with a legal system saying: this is the sentence.
One man overruled all of it. The 563 inmates found out before the families did.