Three Judges, Five Releases, One Dead Woman in Chinatown

0
Three Judges, Five Releases, One Dead Woman in Chinatown

On November 19, Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Juliet Howard released 25-year-old Alexander Florentino on charges of petty larceny and criminal possession of stolen property. The next afternoon, at approximately 3:22 p.m., a 62-year-old woman was found unconscious with trauma to her face and neck inside her apartment at 27 Catherine Street in Chinatown. She was pronounced dead at NYC Health + Hospitals/Bellevue.

Florentino had been arrested the day before his release. He had 38 prior arrests since the previous year. Judge Howard put him back on the street anyway.

The NY Post reported that court records show Florentino was released by New York City judges five separate times since August before the killing. The timeline is worth reading slowly.

August 3: arrested for criminal possession of stolen property. September 2: arrested for criminal mischief and attempted arson. September 28: Judge Jeffrey Gershuny released him after another arrest for petit larceny and stolen property. October 21: a warrant was issued because Florentino failed to show up for court. November 13: Judge Valentina Morales released him with non-monetary conditions on charges dating back to August. November 18: arrested again. November 19: Judge Howard released him. November 20: a woman was dead.

Florentino is now charged with murder, attempted murder, two counts of strangulation, burglary, assault, and attempted assault. The 66-year-old male roommate who came home during the attack was beaten with a glass bottle and suffered a laceration to his face. He's in stable condition at Bellevue.

Judge Howard is a Democrat who took office in January 2026. Before that, she worked at the Legal Aid Society. Judge Morales is a former public defender from the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem, appointed by Bill de Blasio in 2021 and reappointed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani just this month. Judge Gershuny was publicly censured last month for a courtroom handgun "experiment."

These are the people deciding who walks and who doesn't.

The timing makes the politics worse. Mayor Mamdani has just announced a six-year plan to close Rikers Island by 2032, reducing the jail population from approximately 6,700 to 4,100. The goal is fewer people in custody. Alexander Florentino was one of the people not in custody. He had five open criminal cases and was scheduled to appear across five Manhattan Criminal Court dockets on December 14.

The system didn't fail because nobody saw this coming. The system saw it coming five times. Five arrests. Five appearances before judges. Five decisions to release. Each judge looked at Florentino's record — the growing list of charges, the missed court date, the warrant — and decided the answer was more non-monetary conditions and another court date.

A 62-year-old woman in Chinatown didn't get a sixth chance to lock her door.

Five open cases. December 14 court date. She won't be there to see it.


Most Popular

Most Popular